Tuesday, September 16, 2008

An Introduction to Barlow's The Summe and Substance of the Conference.

2. The Commission

Was the publication of a account of the Hampton Court Conference Bancroft’s idea? Curtis leaves no doubt that “a few weeks after” the conference ended, Barlow was “commissioned by Bancroft to compile from his own notes and those of other conferees an account of the proceedings which could be published.” On might imagine from so clear a statement that the instructions had been preserved. In fact, the only information about the origins of The Summe and Substance comes from William Barlow’s own hand, and it is not at all as clear. It need only be noted in passing that he does not mention when he was asked to produce a summary of the conference. or that he was told to use the notes of other participants. He could have been asked before the conference began, or the day after it ended, or even after it was known that unauthorized reports were circulating: which it was is simply unknown. That such reports were in circulation is well known; Barlow himself printed three as an appendix to his book. He notes that “many copies” had been sent to him, of which he had chosen the least offensive.[1] But this does not show that he was writing specifically in answer to them. We will consider these “copies” further when we turn to Barlow’s sources. Because there is no evidence, any reason that can be given for the commissioning of a semi-official account of the conference will quite simply be a more or less well educated guess.
If he said too little about when and why he was given this task, Barlow might have said too much about who laid it on him. In the preface to The Summe and Substance, he stated that the task of writing it had been “first imposed” on him by John Whitgift, the Archbishop of Canterbury, whose death was one of the reasons the appearance of the account was delayed.
[2] However, Barlow also stated in his letter to Cecil of 12 May that "the charge" of publishing a true account of the conference had been put on him by the Bishop of London.[3] The apparent contradiction might be solved by ignoring one of Barlow’s statements, as Curtis did. It is however quite likely that Barlow was Whitgift’s choice for the task. The Archbishop died on February 29th, after which Bishop Bancroft of London continued or possibly even renewed the commission. Whitgift’s early interest in and patronage of Barlow makes it seem likely that the choice was his..
C. S. Knighton’s life of Barlow in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography does not need to be repeated here, but makes Whitgift’s patronage clear.
[4] The ecclesiastical lawyer Richard Cosin who has supported Barlow’s education introduced him to Archbishop Whitgift, thereby laying the foundation for his advancement. Barlow became a chaplain to the Archbishop. In August 1596 was chosen to preach at Paul’s Cross in celebration of Essex’ victory at Cadiz.[5] The following year Whitgift saw to suitable preferment for him, but was unable to get him appointed as to a royal chaplaincy for some years. According to John Harington, Barlow preached many times before Queen Elizabeth, who said of one sermon, “of the plough”, “Barlow’s text might seem taken from the cart, but his talk may teach you all the court.”[6] In 1601, now a royal chaplain, he delivered two more official sermons. At Paul’s Cross on March 1st, the Sunday following the execution of the earl of Essex, he preached a sermon that incorporated an official explanation of the execution, in which Barlow carefully followed guidelines set out for him by Robert Cecil, the Secretary of State. In October he delivered the Latin sermon at the opening of the Convocation of the Province of Canterbury, a sermon “which many (especially puritans) did much mislike” and “called it (alluding to his name) ‘The Barley Loaf’”[7]. In the same year he published a reply to a book by one Thomas Wright against the Protestant religion.[8] Whitgift’s patronage and Barlow’s service in these sermons may explain why this rising cleric was chosen out of all the participants to prepare an account of the conference at Hampton Court in 1604.
Aside from Barlow’s own remarks in the preface to The Summe and Substance and his two letters to Lord Cecil and the entry in the Stationers’ Register, no information has survived about the reason the work was commissioned or when it was commissioned, nor (as we have seen) about when precisely it was published. Anything that might be said about these matters is speculative. Barlow states in the preface that the account of the Conference was “long expected”; he wrote the same to Cecil on 12 May. This certainly means that it was no secret that a report of the Conference was being prepared. Barlow also gives two reasons that this long expected work was delayed. The first was the death of John Whitgift. The Archbishop died on February 29th, which gives a terminus ante quem for the commission. The other was

an expectation of this late Comitial Conference, much threatened before and triumphed in by many; as if that regal and most honourable proceeding, should thereby have received his Counter–blast for being too forward.

“Comitial Conference”probably means Parliament, although we find in the OED that "comitial" was also used at the time for a general assembly or synod of presbyterians. The likely meaning is that Barlow expected something to be raised in the session of Parliament to undo the work that had been done at Hampton Court, though it is not clear why this should have delayed his book. A third reason for the delay, not mentioned in the preface, appears in the letters to Cecil. On May 12 Barlow requested that Cecil accept the dedication of The Summe and Substance. Sometime after the book was published, he sent a copy to Cecil, who had refused to accept the dedication withut reading the book and then “inhibited access” to Barlow, who would not take any other patron, and so published it without a patron
.Mark Curtis says that Robert Cecil’s refusal to accept the dedication to The Summe and Substance was ‘significant’. However, it was not so much that Cecil refused the dedication but that (as Pauline Croft put it) he “wriggled out of” it. Cecil might have had several reasons to avoid accepting the dedication, and none of them can prove, that he thought it was inaccurate. How could they? Cecil had not read or even seen The Summe and Substance, and could have had no opinion at all on its accuracy. Croft’s suggestion is that Cecil "wriggled out of" accepting the dedication to show that he "dissociated himself from the hardline conformists. Moreover, this was not the only commitment he avoided at that time. He was also careful to distance himself from those who disturbed the church with their refusal to use the prayer book or surplice, "evading the assiduous efforts of Sir Francis Hastings to lobby him just before the publication of the proclamation of July 1604.”[9]
Barlow was careful to state that The Summe and Substance was not a verbatim report of the sessions at Hampton Court but an extract and summary. Knighton sees this as a sign that Barlow had foreseen controversy, which likely. Te puritan understanding of a proper conference tended also defined what was acceptable as a record of the meeting. A petition of 1586 from "Some Students of the University of Cambridge" that asked for a "free disputation" on the question "Whether the Churches are to be governed by the Lord Bishops and their Chancellors, or Signories", notaries were to take down the arguments on either side so that they could be properly judged.” [10] One of the reasons the radical minister Henry Jacob refused to accept that the meeting at Hampton Court fulfilled the puritan request for a conference was that the report had been prepared by only one side. In the conference he modestly offered the report would be written up and approved by both sides. (The discussion would apparently be in writing as well).[11] It is not known whether any official notes were taken at the conference, since the records of the Privy Council in that period have been lost. No other official record of the meetings was published. We will return to the reaction to The Summe and Substance, in the next section, after concluding this one with a note of Barlow’s sources.
Barlow stated that for the first day’s meeting he “had no help, beyond mine owne,” but that “some of good place and understanding have seen it, and not controlled it, except for the brevity.” It is too bad that he does not name these persons of good place, since they apparently approved (did not control) his account. For the second and third day as well as his own notes he had those of several participants, who are named in the margin. They were: Richard Bancroft, Bishop of London, Thomas Ravis, Dean of Christchurch, Oxford; George Abbot, Dean of Winchester; Giles Tomson, Dean of Windsor; and John King, Archdeacon of Nottingham. None of these accounts have survived. Barlow was also was aware of other anonymous accounts of the conference, three of which he printed in an appendix and stated to be “untrue”.He does not mention that he used or knew of the accounts of Toby Matthew, the Bishop of Durham, and James Montagu, Dean of the Chapel Royal, which have survived, possibly because they were private letters. This strengthens the value of those two letters as independent eye-witness accounts of the conference.
We may note here that the marginal list of accounts the only hint in The Summe and Substance that George Abbot (later Archbishop of Canterbury) had been a participant in the conference. It seems likely that Abbot was present: the Harleian Account does mention Winchester among the deans, while an “Anonymous Account in favour of the Bishops”, Baker MSS M.m.1.45, f. 155-157, printed in Usher Reconstruction of the English Church, ii. 335-338, lists “Abbotts” among the “anti-puritans”. Neither Matthew nor Montagu give a list of the deans at the conference. I can think of no reason why Barlow did not list Abbot with the other deans on page1 except sloppiness. The dean of Salisbury, who is mentioned on page 3, is also left off the list.
[12].

NOTES

[1] Barlow. Sig P1 recto.
[2] Barlow, Sig A2 recto.
[3] HMC Salisbury xv, p. 95.
[4]. ODNB, 3. 940-942
[5] This was was a preaching cross and open air pulpit by old St Paul's Cathedral in London.
[6] John Harington, Nugae Antiquae, ed. by Thomas Park (London: 1804), ii. 197-8.
[7] Ibid, ii. 197. Harington remarks that Barlow’s opponents did not realize “how much honour rhey give it in their scorn”, for in the O.ld Testament the barley loaf “signified Gideon’s sword, ordained to destroy the sicked” (see Judges 7.13-14), and in the New “by the blessing of our Saviour, it fed more thousands of men than this ofended” (see John 6.9).
[8] A defence of the articles of the Protestants religion, in aunsweare to a libell lately cast abroad, intituled Certaine articles, or forcible reasons, discouering the palpable absurdities, and most intricate errours of the Protestantes religion (London, for Mathew Law, 1601) STC1449
[9] Pauline Croft, "The Religion of Robert Cecil", p. 776.
[10] The Second Parte of a Register, vol. ii, p. 187.
[11] Jacob, A Christian and Modest Offer, pp. 5, 29.
[12] I am reminded that I have not yet posted a revised list of the clerical participants in the conference. This will come.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

An Introduction to William Barlow's The Summe and Substance of the Conference

Note: With this post I begin to present the material about William Barlow's Summe and Substance from my thesis in what I hope is a more readable form. Sections will be posted as they are completed. After the elementary questions about the publication what I believe would be most useful is an annotated edition of Barlow's work, but I am not sure how practical that would be for posting on a blog. Either in that way or some other, the main point of this introduction will be to address the question of reliability that has been raised against Barlow's account.
In quotations the spelling has been modernized for the convenience of the readers.

An Introduction to William Barlow’s
The Summe and Substance of the Conference
Part I

The Hampton Court Conference ended on January 18th 1604. Then or sometime afterwards one of the clergy who had participated in the confreence, William Barlow, was commissioned to produce an account of the meetings. Working with his own notes and those of other participants, Barlow produced an account which was titled The Summe and Substance of the Conference. It was, he said,

an Extract, wherein is the Substance of the whole; intercourse of speeches, there occasioned, would cause prolixity without profit: what every man said, point devise, I neither could, nor cared to observe; the vigour of every objection, with the sum of each answer, I guess, I miss not:[1]

If it is only an extract, The Summe and Substance is still the longest and most detailed account we have of the Hampton Court Conference. The other accounts which have survived are for the most part private letters, with the exception of the anonymous account from Harleian MS 828, first printed by R. G. Usher in 1910, which at 5,400 words or so is about a third the length of Barlow’s account. The first edition of the Summe and Substance was a quarto volume of about 120 pages, containing a preface, “To the Reader”, the account of the conference, and an appendix of “copies”, that is, other accounts of the conference then in circulation which Barlow asserted were “untrue”.
Although it was long accepted as accurate and authoritative, Barlow's account has been also been accused of inaccuracy and bias. In recent times the latter opinion has gained ground, and other accounts have been put forward as correctives, so that as C. S. Knighton stated in his life of Barlow in the ODNB, “The extent to which Barlow’s summary does indeed convey the substance remains central to the historiography of the conference”.
[2] It seems to me that this central question requires a simple and clear study of Barlow’s work, to measure it against the other pieces in the historical record of the conference.
This introduction to The Summe and Substance begins with a note of its publication history. and of the question of justy when it was published.. That leads us to ask who commissioned Barlow to do this work, and why Barlow was the one commissioned. With that groundwork laid the work itself can be examined.

1. The Publication of the Summe and Substance
Barlow’s work was entered by the bookseller Matthew Law with the Company of Stationers on 22 May 1604 in accordance with the law concerning book publishing. The entry was “under the hands of” Master Pasfield, Doctor Barlow, the Bishop of London, and the wardens of the company.[3] Law brought out two quarto editions in 1604 and one in 1605.[4] Three further editions of appeared in 1605, 1625, and 1638.[5] After September 1604 Robert Barker, the King’s Printer, issued a French translation, La conference tenuë à Hamptoncour in which Barlow’s account was bound with a translation of the new Canons, which Convocation had approved on June 25th and the King ratified on September 6th.[6] It is not known who made this translation or why; the title page states that it was printed in London, but the STC notes “i,e. France?”[7]
This is as good a place as any to note the early publishing history of The Summe and Substance. In 1655 Thomas Fuller copied Barlow's account almost verbatim in his Church History of Great Britain, though he cast it in the form of a dialogue. Another edition of The Summe and Substance was published in 1661.
[8] In 1707 it was reprinted by the bookseller John Dunton in The Phenix, a collection of rare and interesting documents.[9] This reprinting omits the preface "To the reader" and the collection of other accounts at the end of Barlow's book. Edward Cardwell printed the description of the conference from James Montagu's letter of 18 January 1604 in the narrative portion of the History of Conferences, but included Barlow's account in the collection of documents which follows, calling it an "authentic" report. Cardwell did not explain why he made this choice: it may simply have been that Montagu's version of events is shorter than Barlow's. Cardwell included the preface, but not the appendix of anonymous accounts.[10] In recent work, Barlow has often been cited from Cardwell's edition.[11]
Publication Delayed
Barlow began his preface with an apology for the delay in publishing a work that had “been long expected; and long since it was finished.” The conference at Hampton Court ended on January 18th; the book was entered in the Stationers’ register on May 22nd and was presumably then ready for publication. Before examining the explanation Barlow offered for the delay, we must note some confusing evidence. In the ODNB life of Barlow, Knighton states that the draft appeared on 25 May, for which he cites STC 1456. This notes the entry of the book in the register on 22 May, for which “25”might be an error.
It would seem from this that Barlow’s book appeared in late May 1604, three months after the end of the conference, a delay long enough to need some explanation. However, in his important paper on the conference, Mark Curtis suggested that the delay was even longer, for The Summe and Substance “did not come from the press until August.”
[12]
This dating appears to rest on the evidence of two letters from Barlow to Robert Cecil, the king’s Principal Secretary. In the first, written on 12 May, Barlow requested Lord Cecil to accept the dedication of the book, which was then ready to the press. He noted that “His Majesty is pleased with it”. The second letter, which is undated, is summarized as follows in the calendar:

He purposed the dedication of the accompanying book to Cecil, who required sight thereof before the edition; but was inhibited access to him, and it was called upon to the press, and was, after a thorough view by Sir Thomas Lake, allowed by my Lord of London. He would not take any other patron but Cecil, and therefore has sent it abroad without patronage. If it had been printed with Cecil's name, he trusts his carriage therein is such that Cecil would not have found dishonour by the book, or discredit by the compiler.[13]

The clear meaning of this letter is that the book which accompanied it had already been published, not that it was simply “ready to come from the press”. Barlow tells Lord Cecil not that he “was about to” publish the book but that he “has [already] sent it abroad.”.
That this was in August 1604 seems to be deduced from fact that the letter is dated in the Calendar, “1604, before August 20”. By itself that might suggest that the letter was written sometime in August 1604, but this idea is weakened by closer examination. It appears that there are many letters in the calendar are dated the same way and for the same reason. On August 20th 1604 Robert Cecil, who had been created Baron Cecil of Essenden on May 13th 1603, was made Viscount Cranborne; undated letters addressed to “Lord Cecil” are calendared as "before August 20.” As evidence for the publication of Barlow’s book, then, this date is a red herring. There is no reason to suppose that it came out much later than the end of May.
[14]
One reason for taking note of the date of publication is that Curtis deduced from it the “chief purpose” for which Barlow had been commissioned to prepare an account of the conference, which was so that it would appear after the adjournment of Parliament and Convocation and so provide “an argument for compliance with Bancroft’s own scheme of ecclesiastical reform as that had been embodied during the summer in the Canons of 1604.”[15] If the publication was not delayed so long as that, such an interpretation needs to be reconsidered, at least. Another reason for questioning it is that it assumes that a semi-official account of the conference was Bancroft’s idea, a claim that there is reason to question.

Notes
[1] William Barlow, The Svmme and Svbstance of the Conference, which, it pleased his Excellent Maiestie to haue with the Lords, Bishops, and other of his Clergie, (at which the most of the Lordes of the Councell were present) in his Maiesties Priuy-Chamber, at Hampton Court. Ianuary 14. 1603 Contracted by William Barlovv, Doctor of Diuinity, and Deane of Chester. Whereunto are added, some copies, (scattered abroad,) vnsauory, and vntrue. (London. John Windet (and T. Creede) for Matthew Law, and are to be sold at his shop in Paul’s Churchyard, near St Austin’s Gater, 1604), Sig A3 recto.
[2] ODNB, 3.940-942, 941
[3] A Transcript of the Registers of the Company of Stationers of London 1554-1640 AD, edited by Edward Arber (London: privately printed, 1876) iii.110. “Master Pasfield” is Zacharias Pasfield, later a prebendary of St Paul’s.
[4] Short Title Catalogue, second edition: 1456, 1456.5 (both printed by John Windet and T. Creede), and 1457 (printed by Valentine Simmes)
[5] STC: 1457-1458.
[6] E B. Fryde et al, Handbook of British Chronology (London: Royal Historical Society, 1986); Gerald Bray, Anglican Canons, 1529-1947 Church of England Record Society (Woodbridge, Sussex: The Boydell Press, 1998) pp. lv-lix.
[7] STC, 1459, “A Londres [i.e. France?] : par Robert Barker, imprimeur de la tres-excellente Majeste du Roy, l’an 1604.”
[8] Short Title Catalogue of Books Printed in England ... 1641-1700, compiled by Donald Wing, second edition, B847.
[9] John Dunton, The Phenix, or a revival of scarce and valuable pieces from the remotest antiquity down to the present times, being a collection of manuscripts and printed tracts, nowhere to be found but in the closets of the curious, by a gentleman who has made it his business to search after such pieces. (London: for J. Morphew, 1707), pp. 139-180.
[10] Edward Cardwell, A History of Conferences and other proceedings connected with the revision of the Book of Common Prayer... 3rd edition (Oxford: University Press, 1849), pp.138-141, esp. p 138, note k, 167-212.
[11] As for example in Fincham and Lake, "The Ecclesiastical Policy of James I" and Collinson, "The Jacobean Religious Settlement".
[12] Mark H. Curtis, “Hampton Court and its Aftermath”, History: The Journal of the Historical Association XLVI (1961) 1-16, 4
[13] Historical Manuscripts Commission, Calendar of the Manuscripts of the most hon. the marquis of Salisbury, xvi (1933), 95, 242
[14] This is an opportunity to correct an oversight in my doctoral dissertation [The King’s Own Conference: A Reassessment of Hampton Court 1604 (Trinity College, Toronto: 2006), 150 -151], where without carefully examining Barlow’s second letter I had simply accepted Curtis’ statement that The Summe and Substance was not published untill August.
[15] Curtis, 3.

Tuesday, June 3, 2008

The Calling of the Hampton Court Conference: Other Petitions, Documents, and Influences

Even if the Millenary Petition had been presented to the King and read by him on his way to London in the spring of 1603,[1] there is good reason to think that its influence has been exaggerated if it is held, as is often stated, that the Hampton Court Conference was called “in response to the Millenary Petition so that the issues raised by it could be discussed in a formal setting”[2] or that the Millenary Petition as “the original blueprint for discussion” at the conference. It is clear from the various accounts of the conference that neither John Rainolds, the puritan spokesman, nor King James followed it in presenting their agendas.[3] Other influences were clearly at work. Before setting out the evidence for this, it would be helpful to review the information that was circulating in England as James began his reign..
No one in England seems to have been shy about offering information or advice to their new king. As he wrote later to write he had “daily” received "informations” of scandals in the church.[4] The accounts of his progress from Edinburgh mention five petitions of various kinds and on various matters, although none of them can be identified with the Millenary Petition.[5] The State Papers preserve two petitions that are not mentioned in these narratives and are in part concerned with ecclesiastical affairs. One, "The poor man’s petition to the King", is preserved in the State papers and elsewhere. Only two of its fourteen clauses on the Church. One is that the King will "let there be an uniformity in true religion without any disturbance of papist and puritan," and the other that he will "let good preachers be well provided for, and without any bribery come to their livings."[6] The other is a memorandum headed "Things grievous and offensive to the Commonwealth, which may be reformed by the King or by a Parliament".[7] This document is in two parts, one listing abuses in the commonwealth, the other "things grievous and offensive in the Church of England". It not only lists abuses but also suggests appropriate remedies, and includes many points that were to be discussed at the conference, such as impropriated tithes.
Not all the petitions were spontaneous popular demands. A number of documents represent an organized movement to produce petitions from all over the country.[8] The most important of these is the Advices tending to Reformation, which called on noblemen, gentlemen and ministers "to complain of corruption and desire reformation in several petitions". It was printed by Roland Usher in The Reconstruction of the English Church. One copy has been annotated, apparently by Robert Cecil, showing that the government was aware of it.[9] Closely related to this is a letter from Henry Jacob, one of the radical ministers, to puritan preachers which contained a form for use in connection with the presentation of further petitions.[10] Another petition, from some ministers in Sussex, is found in the Cecil papers, where it is dated after October 18.[11] Other material is recorded in what is known as "Smart's Letter Book", a collection of letters and other documents made by a clergyman of Northamptonshire and preserved in BL MS Sloane 271.[12] It also contains the form of petition found in Henry Jacob's letter.[13] On September 24, 1603, the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Bishop of London wrote to Robert Cecil about the petitions of factious clergymen, presumably the ones in Sussex, which quotes the Advice tending to Reformation and refers to Henry Jacob.[14] It is interesting that in this group of petitions, which were produced through to the fall of 1603 there is no mention that a conference had been called to deal with church affairs.

Even without the petitions, James would have been aware of the dissensions in the Church. The matter came to him even before he left Scotland. As soon as it was announced that the old Queen was dead, Lewis Pickering, "a Northamptonshire gentleman, and zealous for the presbyterian party,” decided to appeal in person to the new King. At the same time, Archbishop Whitgift sent Thomas Neville, the Dean of Canterbury, to Edinburgh on behalf of the bishops and clergy. Pickering came swiftly, but it is not known "how far and with what answer he moved the king in that cause".[15] King James told Neville "that he would uphold the Government of the late Queen, as she left it," an answer which was welcome to Whitgift. He and some of the Bishops, particularly Bancroft of London, are said to have feared that the King would "favour the New Discipline", as Strype puts it, and make changes in church government and liturgy.[16] The reply to Neville is the first report that the King's conviction was to uphold the English Church as it had been left him, a conviction that was to be repeated several times over the next year. Perhaps the visits of Pickering and Neville had some influence on the king’s declaration in Edinburgh on 3 April, that “as God has promoved me to a greater power nor I had, so I must endeavour myself to flourish and establish religion, and take away the corruptions of both countries.” [17]
James received one document at about this that seems to have had more influence than any of the petitions, a treatise addressed to him by Francis Bacon called Certain Considerations touching the better pacification and edification of the Church of England. Bacon seems to have presented this to the king soon after his accession. A manuscript copy is in the State Papers;[18]. one MS copy adds to the title "at his first coming in." In this treatise Bacon makes no mention of the Millenary Petition or any other petition, or that a conference is being planned. He is aware of the need for reform, and discusses most of the plans for reform that were in the air, taking a moderate and independent line on them.[19] In this tract Bacon treated all but one of the points that the King was to raise at Hampton Court on the first day of the conference. Moreover, what James said at that meeting is often similar to Bacon’s tract. The section of this treatise on the liturgy and ceremonies is of particular interest because it includes the three points about the Prayer Book which James later raised with the bishops on the first day of the conference, and seems to have more in common with his presentation than any of the petitions.

There remains a document that probably never came to the king’s notice, but clearly iunfuenced the four ministers in presenting their case. In the Historic Manuscripts Commission report on the Manuscripts of Lord Montagu of Beaulieu is a document which concerns an assembly of puritan ministers which seems to have met at the same time as the king’s conference. This document opens with nine points for which the "brethren chosen to deal for the cause in the conference" should solicit the King “on behalf of the Church in therse points.”. .This is followed by a list of participants in the conference, divided into “Bishops of the Conference,” “Deans,” “Ministers of the Conference,” and two “At their conference and in Place” after which are listed twenty-six ministers “at but not in Place.” Patrick Collinson wrote that the "meeting implies the assumption on the puritan side that they were to be represented at the conference by delegates, and the thirty ministers who attended represented their own 'countries'".[20] He also suggested that this delegation "was reminiscent of the parliamentary lobbies of the 1580s, with the delegates mostly survivors of the earlier campaigns".[21]
It now remains to examine what signs there are in the course of the Hampton Court Conference of whether it was meant to be a discussion of the Millenary Petition or not.
NOTES

[1] Anglican and Episcopal History 77:1 (March 2008), 46-70
[2] See http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/Hampton_Court_Conference.htm.
[3] Tyacke, Anti-Calvinists, pp. 22-3
[4] Proclamation of 24 October, 1603.
[5]An English Garland: Stuart Tracts 1603-1693, with an Introduction by C. H. Firth. (New York: Cooper Square Publishers, 1964), pp. 30, 32, 38, 40, 58.
[6] SPD James I 14/1/A, B. A copy dated 1603 is found in the papers of F. H. T. Jervois, in HMC, Various Manuscripts, volume IV, p. 166. A MS at Exeter Cathedral included by John Nichols in his Progresses ... of James I, claims that it was presented at Robert Cecil's house, Theobalds (pronounced "Tibbalds"), where the King arrived on 3 May. However, since this petition is filed with a letter of the Privy Council to Robert Cecil dated 17 April it may be supposed that it was presented before the King came to Theobalds. It also shows that it was known to the government, and might have been seen by the King.
[7] SPD James I, 14/1/68 dated May, 1603.
[8] See Collinson, Elizabethan Puritan Movement, pp 452-4.
[9] Usher, Reconstruction ii. 358-9, printed from BL Additional MSS. 28471, f. 199, a Secretarial Copy, underlined by another hand. Usher says that internal evidence fixes the date as between May 12 and June 1.
[10] This letter is printed in part in the Oxford University Answere to the Millenary Petition and C. Burrage, Early English Dissenters,vol ii, p. 146f.
[11] HMC Salisbury xv. 262
[12] Collinson, Elizabethan Puritan Movement, p. 453.
[13] This form is printed in W. J. Sheils, The Puritans in the Diocese of Peterborough 1558-1610, p. 73, from BL Sloane MS 271, f. 20; it is also found in C. Burrage, Early English Dissenters, vol ii, p. 147, printed from MS Harl 6849, fol 254, with another version from Lambeth Palace Library MS 113fol 242f; and in the Oxford Answere. It is strange that this manuscript, fragments of which are quoted in almost every work on the early Jacobean church, has never been published in full.
[14] SPD James I, 14/3/83.
[15] Fuller, Church History of Britain, iii. 189.
[16] Strype, Whitgift, p. 559-60.
[17] David Calderwood. The History of the Kirk of Scotland, edited by Thomas Thomson. vol. 6. (Edinburgh, Wodrow Society, 1845), pp. 215-16.
[18] Francis Bacon, Certaine Considerations touching the better pacification and Edification of the Church of England: Dedicated to his most Excellent Majestie (London: for Henry Tomes, 1604). The MS in the State Papers, 14/5/51, is dated 1603. The treatise was published at first only in incomplete editions: see Bacon's Works, ed. J. Spedding (London: Longman, Green, Reader and Dyer, 1868), vol. x., p. 102. See also Francis Bacon, edited by Brian Vickers (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996), p. 501
[19] Vickers, op. cit., p. 501.
[20] HMC, MS of Lord Montagu of Beaulieu, pp 32f.; Collinson, Elizabethan Puritan Movement, 456 (the emphasis is mine).
[21] Collinson, "The Jacobean Religious Settlement", p. 37.

Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Dramatis Personae of the Conference

Part II: “Extras”, Clerks, Servants, and Experts
Before turning to the list of clerical participants at the Hampton Court Conference. It is useful to take note of persons who were or might have been present but were not participants. Taking such extra personnel into account is helpful in constructing a picture of that the conference was like.
i. 'Extras'
First, there are three individuals whose writings suggest that they were present at the conference even though they were not participants. To these is added an individual whose present is uncertain, but who ought still to be noted.
26. Sir Roger Wilbraham is not mentioned in any other account of the conference except his own journal, in which he does not explain why he was present.[1] Wilbraham was a Master of the Requests and former Solicitor General in Ireland. Although Masters of the Requests were not automatically Privy Counsellors they were sometimes summoned to meetings of the council. There is no reason to doubt Wilbraham's claim that he was present for all three days of the conference
27. Dudley Carleton described the first day of the conference in a letter to John Chamberlain which is dated from Hampton Court on Sunday, 15 January and preserved in the State Papers. [2] Carleton had been controller of the household to Henry Percy, Earl of Northumberland since September 1603.[3] He is not mentioned in any accounts of the conference, and in his letter he does not claim that he was at the meeting. If he was not, he is possibly passing on information that came to him from Northumberland. If he was present, the possibility arises that other Privy Counsellors had attendants with them at the conference, and the task of trying to ascertain who was present becomes even more difficult.
28. Sir John Harrington, who was godson of Queen Elizabeth I, wrote an account of the conference for his wife, which sounds for all the world like the report of someone who was listening at the door.[4] From the internal evidence, and in particular his reference to Reynolds, it seems he was only present on the second day of the conference, and apparently at the invitation of Bishop Bancroft. He says: "I cannot be present at the next meeting, though the bishop of London said I might be in the ante‑chamber."
29. If only for completeness’ sake it should be mentioned that R. G. Usher stated that the Genevan envoy was also present. [5] This person is not mentioned in any of the accounts of the conference.
ii Clerks and Servants
Although none of the accounts of the conference mention such staff as one might expect to find in attendance. But it might be reasonable to suppose that someone was there to take notes. or to produce a list of the matters that were decided. It is not unusual for such persons to be overlooked. Though they would not have taken part in the discussions or influenced the decisions, they were eyes and ears at an event that seems to have provoked much gossip, and could have been sources of information. Five clerks of the Council are mentioned in the first months of James I's reign: Anthony Ashley, William Waad, Thomas Smith, Thomas Edmonds, and Ralph Winwood, who may be numbered 30-34 in our list of persons who might have been present. The records also name two Keepers of the Council Chamber, Alexander Dowglasse and Humfrey Rogers, who may be numbered 35 and 36. Dowglasse, or Douglas, was a Scot.[6]
iii. Experts
On the third day of the Conference Whitgift called in legal experts, who are mentioned only in Barlow's: account, although Tobie Matthew informed Archbishop Hutton that one of them, Sir John Bennet could give him further information on the conference. These were "the knights and doctors of the Arches", that is, the court of the Province of Canterbury.[7] Barlow names [37] Sir Daniel Dunne, [38] Sir Thomas Crompton, [39] Sir Richard Swale, [40] Sir John Bennet, and [41] Dr Drury. Barlow gives us no idea of the role they played at the conference, saying only that they were called by the archbishop and that they were amazed by the King's ability to express himself. Strype says that they were summoned on the third day because the ecclesiastical courts were "then to be justified".[8]

[1] "The Journal of Sir Roger Wilbraham", edited by Harold Spencer Scott, in The Camden Miscellany, vol X (London: Royal Historical Society, 1902), pp. 66-67.
[2] SPD, James I, 14/6/21: printed in Dudley Carleton to John Chamberlain, pp 53-59, and in Shriver, "James I and The Puritans", p. 59.
[3] Maurice Lee, Jr., ed. Dudley Carleton to John Chamberlain 1603-1624: Jacobean Letters. (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1972) pp. 7f.
[4] Nugae Antiquae, by Sir John Harington, Knt., and others, selected by the late Henry Harington, newly arranged by Thomas Park. 2 volumes. (London: by J. Wright for Vernor & Hood, &c., 1804), 1.181.
[5] Usher, Reconstruction, i. 316 and note 2.
[6] Acts of the Privy Council of England, 498, B. Galloway, The Union of England and Scotland, 1603-1608, p. 25 n. 15.
[7] Barlow, Summe and Substance, M3r.
[8] Strype, Whigift, p. 573.

Monday, May 26, 2008

Dramatis Personae of the Conference

A Note on Lord Henry Howard
The list of Privy Counsellors who particpated in the conference given in the anonymous Harleian Account includes Lord Henry Howard, under the title "Lord Northampton". It should be noted that since Howard was not given this title until 13 March 1604, this account must have been written after that date. This account makes no other mention of Lord Henry Howard, or that he took any part in the conference. No other document clearly states that Howard was present at the conference: two accounts that seem to suggest that he was at the conference, but might be interpreted otherwise; one statement appears to be evidence against his presence.
One passage which suggests that Howard was present is in the "Anonymous Account in favour of the Bishops". Among four notes at the end of the document is a comment about practices at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, of which Laurence Chaderon was Master. "Chaderton must conform, and his irregular college to wear the surplice, and receive the communion kneeling or else be put out of it. The King imposed this by reason of information given him by the Lord Henry". This statement might mean that Lord Henry was at the conference and gave the information to the King there, but it might just as well mean that the King said, "We have heard such and such about Emmanuel College from Lord Henry Howard". The other text that might be evidence of Lord Henry Howard's presence at the conference is in William Barlow's Summe and Substance. This reference comes in the discussion of popish and seditious books:
My Lord Cecill here taxing, also, the unlimited liberty of the dispersing and divulging there Popish and seditious Pamphlets, both in Pauls Churchyard, and the Universities, instanced one lately set forth, and published, namely, Speculum Tragicum, which both his Majestie & the Lord Henry Howard, now Earl of Northampton, termed a dangerous book, both for matter & intention.
This is a speech in which Robert Cecil reported that the King and the Lord Henry Howard called the Speculum Tragicum a dangerous book, that is, that he had heard them say so, not necessarily that they said it at the conference.
The third piece of evidence is against Howard's presence. It is the letter in cipher of the King undated but ascribed to some point during or just after the conference, and taken as decribing it [see Akrigg, Letters of James VI & I, p. 221]. The relevant passage begins: "We have kept such a revel with the Puritans here these two days, as was never heard the like: where I have peppered them as soundly as ye have done the Papists there". The recipient is clearly somewhere else (although it cannot be known to which place "there" refers) where he has been dealing with papists and not at Hampton Court. Later the King writes, "I was forced at last to say ...”: this cannot be meant for someone who had heard what the King had said. That the absent recipient was the Lord Henry Howard is shown by the code the King used for his correspondents. The letter begins, "My honest black, I dare not say faced, 3," (a blank space precedes "faced"). In James’ code, the numeral 3 stands for Henry Howard. But since the king would hardly have written a letter to Howard describing his "revel" if Howard had been there and taken part, the natural conclusion from this letter is that Lord Henry Howard had not been present at the conference.
On the other hand, it should be remembered both Dudley Carleton and Levinus Munck mention Lord Henry Howard as one of the Privy Counsellors who were at Richmond the day before the conference. Others who were present at that meeting also attended Hampton Court: Howard did not miss the conference because he was too far away.
Another possibilty is that the king’s letter refers to another event and not the conference at Hampton Court, but it would be necessary to find what event it does refer to. This is perhaps another area in the history of the conference where more work is needed.

Dramatis Personae of the Conference

Part I: The King and Privy Council
Missing from the literature of the Hampton Court Conference, both contemporary documents and modern studies,is a definite list of the participants. The list of the bishops, deans and ministers who took part has been generally established, and some writers, particularly Nicholas Tyacke, have made important comments about these clergy who were invited to the conference.[1] Other participants have not been so carefully identified. Moreover, it appears that some people who were not participants were also present for some of the time. As accurate a list of participants as possible would seem to be a useful tool in trying to establish the history of the conference. Not the least important reason for this is so that we might have an idea of how many people were physically present, and from have an idea of what it must have been like for them.
In this paper I have made use of all the surviving accounts and notices of the conference in order to establish a list of particpants and other who may have been present. The first part lists the Kin and the Privy Council.

A. The King and Prince Henry
1. King James VI & I (1566-1625). No comment on the King is needed here.
2. Henry Frederick, Prince of Wales (1594-1612). Only William Barlow’s The Summe and Substance mentions that King James’ elder son was present for the second day of the conference. Prince Henry, who was nearly ten years old, took no active part in the meeting. In 1606 the Prince would likewise be present for part of the King's conference with eight Scottish ministers.[2] His presence at these events was part of his education in the craft of kingship.

B. The Lords of the Council.
Members of the Privy Council also attended the meetings at Hampton Court. In the proclamation of 24 October 1603 James had stated that the conference on ecclesiastical matters was not to be a synod but a body called to advise the King and Council. If in the meetings with the bishops and other learned men he was to find that there were corruptions “which deserve a review and amendment", he will himself "therein proceed according to the laws and customs of this realm by advice of our council, or in our high court of parliament, or by convocation of our clergy, as we shall find reason to lead us".[3] If the Counsellors were to advise the king, it was necessary that they were present at these meetings.
It is not known exactly which Consellors were present. The title page of The Summe and Substance states that "most of the Lords of the Council were present". At the time of the conference the Privy Council had twenty-four members, and the ones who are noted in accounts of the conference are hardly "most" of them. Barlow only mentions the Treasurer, the Chancellor, the Chamberlain, and the king’s principal secretary, Lord Robert Cecil in the narrative of the meeting. The anonymous Harleian Account lists nine counsellors as present: The Lord Chancellor, the Earl of Nottingham, the Earl of Devonshire, the Lord Treasurer, the Lord Chamberlain, the Lord Cecill, the Lord Worcester, Lord Northampton, the Lord Chief Justice ‘at Kingston’. However, only Robert Cecil, the Chancellor, the Lord Chief Justice, and the Lord Admiral are named in that text. Some other accounts name individual counsellors in the course of the narrative, but do not give a list.
To allow a reasonable estimate to be made of which Privy Counsellors were present, the following list includes all members at the time of the conference and states whether they are mentioned in the accounts and any other reason for thinking they might or might not have been present. The only exception is the Archbishop of Canterbury. Although Whitgift was a Privy Counsellor, he did not attend the conferfence as such and is here listed later, among the Bishops.
This list is a shortened form of the one in chapter 2 of The King’s Own Conference, which includes more exensive notes, especially on the religious views of the Counsellors.
3. Sir Thomas Egerton, Baron Ellesmere & Viscount Brackley (1540?-1617), Lord Chancellor. The sources generally agree that he attended the conference, and took an active part on the second and third days.[4]
4. Sir Thomas Sackville, Lord Buckhurst (1536-1608), Lord Treasurer. is mentioned in both the anonymous Harleian Account and Barlow’s The Summe and Substance.[5]
5. Ludovick Stewart, second Duke of Lennox (1574-1624), was the eldest son of Esmé, first duke of Lennox, a cousin and "favourite" of the young King James. He was named to the English Privy Council on 4 May 1603, and naturalized in England on 18 June. It was reported that James meant to make Lennox Lord President of the Council, but in fact he did not do so.[6] Lennox is not mentioned in any of the accounts of the Conference: it is uncertain whether he attended.
6. Charles Howard, Earl of Nottingham (1536-1624), Lord Admiral of England, is not mentioned by Barlow, but the Harleian Account says that he was at the Conference and spoke on the apparel of ministers, and in favour of conformity.[7] The day before the conference, Friday, 13 January 1604, Nottingham had met with the Spanish ambassador at Richmond, about five miles from Hampton Court, along with the Earls of Northumberland and Devonshire, Lord Cecil, and Lord Henry Howard, so there is no reason he could not have been at Hampton Court for the conference.[8] It is reasonable to suppose that he favoured conformity.
7. Henry Percy, ninth Earl of Northumberland (1564-1632), had been appointed to the Privy Council by James on 25 April 1603. Northumberland is not mentioned in any of the accounts of the conference, but since he was at the meeting at Richmond the day before the conference, he could easily have been present at the conference. It should also be noted that his household Controller, Dudley Carleton, was at Hampton Court at the time of the conference and wrote an account of the first meeting. Carleton’s knowledge would be more easily understood if Northumberland had taken part in the meeting.
8. Gilbert Talbot, seventh Earl of Shrewsbury (1553-1616), had been a Privy Counsellor since Elizabeth’s time, James continued him in the council but gave him no new offices. Shrewasury spent most of his time at Sheffield castle and there is no reference in any document to his attendance at the Hampton Court Conference. That he might not have been at the conference is suggested by the notice in eh Journal of Cecil’s secretary Levinus Munck that letters were sent to Shrewsbury at Sheffield from court in late December.
9. George Clifford, third Earl of Cumberland (?-1605) was named to the Privy Council by James on 25 April. There is no reference to him in connection with the conference, and no particular reason to think that he was present.
10. Edward Somerset, fourth earl of Worcester (1553-1628), had been appointed to the Council in 1601 and was continued by James. The Harleian account lists him as at the Conference but does not mention that he took an active part. There is no reason to doubt that he was present.
11. John Erskin, Earl of Mar (1558-1634), was one of the noblemen who accompanied King James from Edinburgh on 5 April 1603: at York he turned back to join Queen Anne. He was named to the Privy Council of England on 4 May 1603 but is not mentioned in any account of the conference. However, Ralph Winwood's Memorials record a letter from the Council of 23 December which Mar and others signed.[9] If Mar was at Court as late as Christmas, he may well have been present at the conference, even though there is nothing to show that he took an active part.
12. Thomas Howard, first Earl of Suffolk (1561-1626), the Lord Chamberlain, had been appointed to the Council on 4 May 1603. He and his uncle Henry had worked closely with Cecil in arranging the peaceful accession of James I. He was at the conference: not only is he listed by the Harleian Account, but Barlow notes that it was he that who shut the door after the bishops had entered the Privy Chamber on the first day of the conference.[10] There is no other record of his participation.
13. Lord Henry Howard, Earl of Northampton (1540-1614), second son of Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, and grandson of the third Duke of Norfolk, had been named to the Privy Council on 4 May 1603.[11] He was made Lord Warden of the Cinque Ports on 1 January 1604, and on 13 March following was created Baron Howard of Marnhull, Devonshire, and Earl of Northampton. Although he is mentioned in some accounts of the conference, he is the only counsellor about whose attendance there is any serious question: a more detailed discussion of this point is given below.
14. Charles Blount, Lord Mountjoy, Earl of Devonshire, (1563-1606), had succeeded the Earl of Essex as Lieutenant in Ireland, defeated Tyrone's rebellion early in 1603, and was called back to England by James. Mountjoy was named to the Privy Council on 25 April and on 12 July was created Earl of Devnshire. The Harleian account lists Devonshire as having being at the conference, but mentions no active part he took in the meeting. He was one of the counsellors who met with the Spanish Ambassador at Richmond on Friday.
15. Sir William Knollys, Treasurer of the Household (1547-1532), is not mentioned in any of the records of the conference, although there is no other evidence for or against his presence at the conference. He is known to have been at Hampton Court on 23 December, since he signed the letter mentioned in the note on the Earl of Mar.
16. Sir Edward Wootton, Comptroller of the Household (1548-1626) is not mentioned in any of the records of the conference, and there is no explicit evidence for or against his presence.
17. Sir John Stanhope, Vice-Chamberlain (1545?-1621), is not mentioned in any of the records of the conference, and there is no evidence for or against his presence at the conference.
18. Robert, Lord Cecil, Secretary of State (1563?-1612), was the son of William Cecil, Lord Burleigh, by his second wife. His father had educated him for service to the sovereign. He had been Secretary of State since 1596, Lord Privy Seal since 1597, and was instrumental in ensuring James's quiet accession to the throne. James continued him in office and created him Baron Cecil of Essendon on 31 May 1603. He is mentioned in both Barlow’s account and the anonymous Harleian account.
19. Sir George Hume, Lord Treasurer of Scotland, Chancellor of the Exchequer (d. 1611), was one of the Scots who accompanied King James to England. He was appointed to the English Council on 4 May, and did not return to Scotland. Sometime after 10 May 1603 he replaced Sir John Fortescue as Chancellor of the Exchequer of England. Although he is not mentioned in any of the records of the conference, he seems to have been at Court at the time of the conference, and so probably attended. In 1605 he was made Earl of Dunbar, and thereafter played a leading part in James's Scottish policies.
20. Sir John Popham, Lord Chief Justice (1531?-1607), had been member of the Privy Council since 1571 and Lord Chief Justice of the King's Bench since 1592. He is not mentioned in The Summe and Substance but is in the second anonymous account printed by Barlow.[12] In the Harleian Account he is mentioned as the "Lord Chief Justice at Kingston". There is no reason to doubt that he attended the conference at Hampton Court, but it cannot be established what part he played in it.
21. Sir James Elphinstone, a Scot, had been appointed to the council 4 May but is not mentioned in any account of the conference. Levinus Munck mentions that Cecil sent a packet to him on 17 December; which suggests that he was then in Scotland, so that it seems unlikely that he was at the conference.
22. Sir John Herbert, second Secretary of State, had been appointed in 1600 and was clearly Cecil's subordinate, popularly known as 'Mr. Secondary Herbert'."[13] On 10 May he was listed in the council, but as then being "at Bremen". The Venetian secretary Scaramelli noted in a letter of 1 May that Herbert was "just returned from his mission (to Copenhagen)".[14] He is again noted as absent on the 10th, and it is not clear whether he was in England at the time of the conference. He is not mentioned in any of the accounts and was probably not at the conference.
23. Edward Bruce, The Lord of Kinloss, (1548/9-1611), accompanied the King to England in 1603, where he was naturalized by an act of parliament and served the crown until his death. He was appointed to the Privy Council on 4 May. Bruce is not mentioned in any account of the conference, but since he was in London at the time may well have been present.
24. Edward La Zouche, eleventh Baron Zouche, Lord President of the Council of Wales (1556?-1625) is not mentioned in any account of the conference. Levinus Munck records that Cecil sent him a packet of letters on 15 January, so that it is most likely that he was not at Court and did not attend the conference.
25. Thomas, Lord Burleigh, Lord President of the Council of the North, was elder son of William Cecil and half-brother of Robert Cecil. He is not mentioned in any account of the conference, and it is unlikely that he was present: Cecil sent him letters on 23 December.[15]

Of the twenty-three Counsellors (apart from the Archbishop of Canterbury), seven were certainly present: Egerton, Buckhurst, Nottingham, Suffolk, Devonshire, Cecil, and Popham. Six more, Northumberland, Worcester, Mar, Knollys, Wotton, and Stanhope, could well have been present. Five members, Shrewsbury, Cumberland, Zouche, Burghley, and Elphinstone, seem to have been too far from London to have attended the conference. Although it is not known where Lord Henry Howard was, he does not appear to have been at the conference, as will be argued in the note below. There is no particular reason to think Sir John Herbert, Kinloss, Lennox, and Home were absent, but we cannot certainly say they were present. Thus it appears that between thirteen and seventeen of the counsellors were at the conference.
[1] Nicholas Tyacke, Anti-Calvinists, pp. 11-22.
[2] James Melvill, The Autobiography and Diary of Mr James Melvill ... with a Continuation of the Diary, edited by Robert Pitcairn (Edinburgh: Wodrow Society, 1842) p. 658.
[3] Proclamation of 24 October, 1603, printed in Cardwell, pp 148-150.
[4] Barlow, Summe and Substance, pp. H4v, J1r, M2v, N1r, N2v, N3v.
[5] Barlow, Summe and Substance, N2v.
[6] Ibid, p 176.
[7] Usher, Reconstruction, ii. 349.
[8] For the meeting at Richmond, see Jones, "The Journal of Levinus Munk, p. 250. This meeting is mentioned by Dudley Carleton, SPD James I 14/6/21.
[9] Ralph Winwood, Memorials of Affairs of State (1725), ii. 12.
[10] Barlow, Summe and Substance, B2r.
[11] Acts of the Privy Council of England. vol. XXXII., p. 496.
[12] Barlow, Summe and Substance, P2v.
[13] Penry Williams, The Later Tudors, p. 374, n.
[14] CSPV x.34
[15] Not numbered in this list is Sir John Fortescue, who had been Chancellor of the Exchequer under Elizabeth and, at first, continued in office by James. He was deprived of office and replaced by Lord Home at some point in May 1603. On Fortescue's loss of office, see N. Cuddy "The revival of the entourage", p. 174f and note 4.

Friday, May 23, 2008

Notes on Documentation

I: Surviving Accounts and other contemporary Notes of the Conference

Sixteen contemporary documents which are either accounts of the Hampton Court Conference or provide significant information about what happened at it have survived. In this list those by persons who attended the whole of the conference are marked **, those by persons who are known only to have been present for some part of the meetings are marked *. Those documents not marked are mostly anonymous.
This list is roughly grouped around the two principal accounts of the Conference, Barlow's (no 1) and the Anonymous Harleyan Account (no 5); nos 9-16 do not fall into either group, chiefly because they are too short and do not report the points where the main accounts differ.
**1 The Summe and Substance of the Conference, by William Barlow, dean of Chester. This is a quasi-official account, commissioned by the Archbishop and approved by the King. It was published in quarto, 103 pages, in the summer of 1604 and reprinted several times, including an edition in French. Reprinted by Cardwell in the History of Conferences. Barlow was a participant in the conference and present at all three sessions.
[We should also note that sometime around 1660, a clergyman of London diocese included a Latin translation of The Summe and Substance in his Gesta Britannica, a collection of notes on English church history, now Stowe MS 76 in the British Library. The catalogue identifies the clergyman as probably Roger Ley or Lea. He did not translate either Barlow’s preface to the reader or the appendix. The BL catalogue states that the MS includes “a discussion of the Hampton Court Conference" but does not note it as a translation of Barlow.]
*2. Dudley Carleton’s letter of 15 January 1604 to John Chamberlain describes the first day of the conference. It is preserved in the UK Public Record Office State Papers (14/6/21) and has been published. The portion of the letter on the conference is 245 words. Dudley Carleton was at Hampton Court but not a participant, but he may have witnessed the meeting on the first day.
**3. A letter of James Montagu, Dean of the Chapel Royal, to his mother written the day the conference ended, gives a brief description of the meetings. It has been published in Cardwell’s History of Conferences where it is in the main narrative. It is approximately 1,170 words long. James Montagu was a participant and present at all three sessions. He does not mention the "false start"on Thursday, January 12.
*4 A letter of Bishop Matthew of Durham wrote to Archbishop Matthew Hutton of York describing the conference written on 19 January. Along with all the bishops but two, Bishop Matthew was not present for the second day of the Conference, 16 January, but was elsewhere, writing up the decisions made on the first day. The letter was printed by John Strype in his Life of Whtigift. A copy of this account from which the personal references have been omitted is found in British Library Egerton MS 2877. This account is about 1,720 words in length.

5. The Anonymous Account in British Library Harley MS 828 and Additional MS 38429, first printed by R. G. Usher in 1910, and put forward by Mark Curtis as a more reliable account than Barlow's. It is somewhat more than 5,000 words in length.
6. An anonymous letter dated 15 January 1604 describing the first day, in general agreement with Harley 828. This letter was the first of three documents printed by Barlow at the end of the Summe and Substance as examples of "untrue" accounts of the Conference which were then in circulation. Reprinted by Usher; 333 words. It should be noted that documents 6, 7, and 9 were in circulation before Barlow completed The Summe and Substance, which he stated in a letter to Lord Cecil on May 12 1604 to be "ready for the press".
7. The second anonymous account printed by Barlow is undated. It reports all three days but gives little detail. Generally agrees with Harleian 828. Reprinted by Usher, 396 words.
*8. A letter from Patrick Galloway to the Presbytery of Edinburgh on 10 February describes the conference very briefly and is more important as a covering letter for a list of the decisions that were made at the Conference, which Galloway claims was amended and approved by King James. Although Galloway claims to have been an “ear and eye-witness”, he was apparently only present at the second session. His letter was published by David Calderwood in the History of the Kirk of Scotland.

9. The third document printed by Barlow is also anonymous and undated. It is not an account of the conference but “some of the speeches that are bruted upon Master Doctor Rainolds return to Oxon. concerning the late conference, before his Majesty.” It presents the conference as an unqualified success for the ministers. 197 words
***10. An undated letter of King James to Lord Henry Howard describes as a “revel with the Puritans”. It is printed in Akrigg, Letters of James VI & I, p. 221.
*11. Thomas Sparke, one of the four ministers, wrote at some length about the conference in A Brotherly Perswasion to Unity, in 1607. He mentions Barlow’s account but does not questioning its accuracy.
*12. Roger Wilbraham, a Master of Requests, wrote a brief description of the conference in his journal. This entry agrees with Barlow at some points. It is not entirely clear why Wilbraham was present at the Conference. [Wilbraham, Roger. "The Journal of Sir Roger Wilbraham, Solicitor-General in Ireland and Master of Requests, for the Years 1593-1616", edited by Harold Spence Scott, in Camden Miscellany X (London: Royal Historical Society, 1902).]
*13. Sir John Harington as also present, but only on the second day; he wrote a brief note in his Nugae Antiquae. He says that the King rather used upbraidings than arguments with the ministers. [Nugae Antiquae, by Sir John Harington, Knt., and others, selected by the late Henry Harington, newly arranged by Thomas Park. 2 volumes. (London : by J. Wright for Vernor & Hood, &c., 1804) ][
14. Reginald Usher printed a document from Baker MSS M.m.1.45, f. 155-157 as Anonymous Account in Favour of the Bishops. It only describes the second session. As an anonymous account there is no way of judging its information. 843 words.
15. A letter which fell into government hands and has been preserved in the State Papers (14/6/37) includes a brief description of the conference. It is impossible to know where the writer, one Ortelio Renzo, obtained his information, or the copy of the brief note of decisions made at the conference that he includes. It has never been printed.
16 An anonymous account of the conference is found in volume IV of the Historic Manuscript Commission report Various Manuscripts, the ms of F. H. T. Jervois. The writer says he is giving information obtained from a friend at Court. It is of little value except for what rumours were circulating about the conference.